In Defence of Disease

← Previous chapter

Next chapter →

Coëxistence

Thus, from the war of nature, from famine and death, the most exalted object which we are capable of conceiving namely, the production of the higher animals, directly follows. There is a grandeur in this view of life, with its several powers, having been originally been breathed into a few forms or into one; and that, whilst this planet has gone cycling on according to the fixed law of gravity, from so simple a beginning endless forms most beautiful and most wonderful have been, and are being, evolved.

—Darwin, Charles. 1861. “Conclusion.” In On the Origin of Species, 425. New York: D. Appleton and Company.

Darwin considered the “most exalted object” that nature produces to be the “higher” animals. However, this romantic view of the nature of ecosystems is true in more ways than he could have known. Not only is death a hammer by which natural selection beats species into “endless forms”, death from disease is the reason so many of these endless forms can coëxist. An outcome of mortality from disease is reduced competition between plant species. It is not an obvious outcome of one organism harming another, but it emerges when we consider the spatial dynamics and evolutionary ecology of plant populations.

First, let's consider an adult tree in fruit. The seeds of the tree land all around, in decreasing amounts as we get further from the trunk. The highest density is right by the base of the tree. Seeds aren't the only thing the tree produces though. Both through the air and under the ground, spores of fungi and oömycetes are also spreading. Adult gall midges and seed weevils fly out from its canopy. Larval mites are blown on the breeze. These, too, land all around the tree, at highest density nearest the trunk, right among most of the seeds! This increased pressure from pests means that seeds are less likely to survive the closer they are to their parent tree.

Now look at the figure below. The black line shows the density of seeds as we get further from the tree (moving right). The yellow line shows the density of species-specific pathogens. In this case, the seeds on average disperse further than the pathogens. As pathogens are more abundant closer to the tree, the death rate of seedlings (purple) is higher. This leads to a dip in seedling density (green) immediately around the tree.

An idealised mathematical model of the Janzen-Connell effect. The code used to generate this figure is available on my GitHub.

This large dip in seedling density appears in the rather extreme case where seeds can spread further than pathogens, but it is illustrative of a more general effect. We can directly observe this in tropical tree seedlings, which have a higher death rate at higher densities unless fungal pathogens are excluded with fungicide1. The death rate immediately around the tree is higher, leading to overdispersion: adult trees are further apart from each other than we would expect based on the distribution of seeds. This is the Janzen-Connell Effect, originally described to explain the mysterious diversity of tropical trees2, most of which more-or-less do the same thing. Ecologists were confused why one species did not simply outcompete all of the others, since they all occupy a similar niche. Connell (1971)3 had the same idea independently, and in fact Gillett (1962)4 beat them both by almost a decade, but his contribution has rarely been acknowledged.

The Janzen-Connell Effect is one strand of a wider phenomenon known as Negative Conspecific Density Dependence (NCDD). This literally means the phenomenon where the competitive fitness of a species decreases as the density of that species increases. The Janzen-Connell Effect refers to the result of increased disease as the density of a species increases, but the same phenomenon also arises from resource competition. Two individuals of the same species use more similar resources (soil nutrients, space) than two individuals of different species. Plants are therefore usually in stronger competition with their own species than they are with other species. As the density of a species increases, an individual of that species is in stronger competition on average with the individual plants around it, as more of them are its conspecific competitors. Therefore, its competitive fitness is lower, as the resources it uses are more depleted. From a population dynamics perspective this and the Janzen-Connell effect look identical, and for that reason the Janzen-Connell effect is often thought of as effective competition between individuals of the same species. Although it is disease spread that causes it, the result is the same as actual competition.

Why only tropical trees?

The Janzen-Connell Effect can explain why such a high number of species can coëxist in communities like tropical forests and grasslands, despite sharing similar ecological niches, but it does not explain why so many species do exist in these communities and not others. For example, boreal forests have very low tree species diversity, with large areas of Earth being covered by just a few conifer species. This does not mean that density-dependent phenomena like the Janzen-Connell Effect are not at play here. It is simply one small part of the story, and we need to look to other parts of ecological and evolutionary theory to explain diversity in these areas. That is beyond the scope of this website, but if you are interested you can find discussion of differences in biodiversity across the globe by searching for papers on the latitudinal diversity gradient, the phenomenon where biodiversity is higher at lower latitudes (the tropics). A good early discussion paper is Gaston (2000)5. More generally, the field that investigates these large-scale patterns in ecology and biodiversity is macroecology.

You may have noticed that the Janzen-Connell Effect only makes sense if the pathogens dispersing from a parent tree are more likely to infect individuals of the same species (the parents' seedlings) than they are other species. It is a result of species-specific pathogens. We will see later that generalist pathogens, which infect many different species, also have a role to play in the structure of plant communities.

Coëxistence Theory

The Janzen-Connell Effect is part of a wider body of work known as Coëxistence Theory. This seeks to explain why, and under what circumstances, different species can coëxist. In many ways it is a field in its infancy: ecosystems are incredibly complex, and being able to predict their dynamics is not something we can do yet. What coëxistence theory has provided is a set of smaller explanations and predictions, and many of these are quite profound. Considering the Janzen-Connell effect, we see the importance of pathogens in maintaining the diversity of an ecosystem. This leads us to the prediction that in their absence, plant diversity would decrease. This is an easily testable hypothesis — we simply take a plant community, remove the pathogens, and see what happens. This is generally done using biocides, particularly fungicides. The result is exactly as we expected: when pathogens are removed, the diversity of the community decreases6. In the same experiment, it was shown that fungi are more important than oömycetes in this effect — when oömyceticide is sprayed, the decrease in diversity is less than when fungicide is sprayed.

Pathogens as equalisers

The other major way pathogens can promote coëxistence is by reducing the competitive difference between species7. Unlike the Janzen-Connell effect, this involves generalist pathogens. Probably the best studied example of this is the parasitic plant Yellow Rattle Rhinanthus spp. It is a bit strange to think of a parasitic plant as a pathogen, but the ecology is similar to that of fungal and oömycetous pathogens: it steals resources for its own reproduction, and has a more rapid lifecycle than its hosts (being an annual plant with generally perennial hosts). It steals water and nutrients by forming specialised root structures called haustoria which latch on to the roots of other plants, forming a connection with the host xylem. It keeps all of its stomata open, letting lots of water out through its leaves. This creates a pressure gradient, so sap is sucked out of the roots of its host. This sap contains water and nutrients used by the parasite for growth and reproduction.

By stealing resources, Yellow Rattle weakens its host. Not all hosts are equally affected though, and the resulting change in community composition has led to its reputation as the ‘meadow maker’. An increasing abundance of Yellow Rattle leads to lower productivity in grasslands8,9. It most negatively affects spreading clonal species such as grasses and other graminoids, benefiting less competitive low-growing species like forbs10. Most studies have found Yellow Rattle has positive or neutral effects on plant species richness11. The details of this illustrate more general processes that mean pathogens can promote coëxistence between plant species.

Graminoids and Forbs

Graminoids are grasses and their close relatives sedges (Cyperaceae) and rushes (Juncaceae). The relevance of these plants to grassland ecology is that they have tall, narrow leaf blades that dominate the vertical space of a grassland, and that they generally grow rapidly, spreading by underground rhizomes to cover large areas. They are strong competitors for light in particular, and are dominant in many grassland ecosystems globally.

Forbs are herbaceous plants that are not graminoids. Most herbaceous plants have much wider leaves and are slower growing than graminoids. They are less strong competitors for light as they generally cannot dominate the vertical space of a grassland like graminoids can.


Dynamic spatial model of Yellow Rattle, Grass, and Forb populations in a grassland. Green = grass, Red = Yellow Rattle, Blue = forb

We can visualise an idealised version of the shift from a plant community dominated by grasses to one dominated by forbs (herbaceous perennials) with a dynamic spatial model12,13. This is a computer simulation programmed with simple equations modelling how different plants compete with each other and disperse across the landscape. In this simulation, Yellow Rattle is not initially present, and the community is dominated by grasses (green). Yellow Rattle (red) is introduced and rapidly proliferates, but it reduces the grass population. As grasses are a better host for Yellow Rattle, this means it quickly runs out of effective hosts. Its population decreases and forbs (blue) become the dominant plants in the community, supporting a lower population of Yellow Rattle. The results of this model can also be visualised as a graph of proportional abundance across the ‘meadow’ shown below:

An idealised model of the effects of introducing Yellow Rattle to a grassland.

Yellow Rattle is not particularly picky about its hosts. It can parasitise most grasses and forbs (herbaceous perennials) in the grasslands where it is found, though some species can avoid being parasitised by forming strong lignin barriers in their roots, or killing tissue around the area it tries to parasitise.14 Why then does it reduce the competitive dominance of grasses, and not simply weaken all of the plant species it parasitises in the community equally? One possibility is that of tradeoffs.

Tradeoffs

Tradeoffs are a fundamental part of evolutionary ecology. The idea is that rather than there being a single optimal strategy or niche a plant can occupy in a given ecosystem, different traits may exist in a tradeoff with one another, such that improvements in one are to the detriment of another. A classic example of this (and one relevant to pathogens mediating coëxistence) is the Growth-Resistance Tradeoff, which is where the growth rate of a plant and its ability to resist environmental pressures like disease, herbivory, and drought are negatively correlated. In a grassland, many grasses have evolved rapid growth, using any resources they acquire to expand rapidly and capture large amounts of light with their leaves. If they are eaten by herbivores, they can simply grow more leaves. In contrast, many long-lived forbs tend to be slower growing, saving their resources and investing in expensive ways to resist and deter herbivores, like toxins, hairs, and spines.

In fact, we can add a third archetype. When an area of grassland is disturbed, for example by the hoof of a grazing animal, small, short-lived plants pop up from the resulting bare soil. They complete their life cycle quickly and invest their resources into producing a large number of seeds. These are ruderals.

These three strategies were the subject of a major breakthrough in plant ecology in the 1970s. Grime (1974)15 considered these archetypes to be the extremes of a spectrum of plant strategies that depend on the relative importance of competition, stress, and disturbance. Grime was rather vague about the difference between stress and disturbance, but for our purposes we can consider that they differ in that stress is continuous (lack of resources, toxins, suboptimal temperatures), while disturbance consists of discrete events (mowing, erosion, fire). Grazing can fit into both of these categories as it is often semi-continuous but still destroys plant biomass in discrete events.

The rapidly spreading grasses follow the competitive strategy, allowing them to use light, water, and nutrients to the exclusion of other species. This strategy is particular prominent in grasslands that rarely experience disturbance such as grazing, which are often dominated by stands of single grass species like Holcus lanatus and Arrhenatherum elatius. Light competition is particularly important here, with grasses’ large leaf surface area shading out other species.

A grassland dominated by Holcus lanatus.

The competitive strategy can be seen in the grassland shown above. This is Lagan Meadows in Belfast in March 2022, which had last been grazed two years before. Disturbance decreased and the importance of competition (particularly for light) increased. This led to Holcus lanatus, a competitive grass, dominating and shading out forb species with its living leaves and the thatch produced as they die.

In contrast, a habitat with a high level of disturbance like trampling, erosion, or fire produces an environment where it is very difficult for a plant to survive for a long period of time. Conditions may be tolerable for a time, but inevitably the disturbance will come and kill the plant at some point. Here the ruderals thrive by growing rapidly, investing in seeds which lie dormant or disperse and escape the disturbance when it kills their parent plant.

Ruderal species including Senecio vulgaris, Arabidopsis thaliana, and Poa annua growing in a pavement in Belfast.

An excellent example of a high-disturbance habitat that of pavements on city streets, where trampling, mowing, and herbicide use decimate plants as often as multiple times per year. This is an extreme habitat where ruderal species thrive. The pavement plants in the image above grow rapidly, completing their life cycle and producing an abundance of seeds that can persist and produce a new generation after a disturbance event. Species such as Senecio vulgaris produce seeds that can disperse long distances (in this case on the wind), escaping to areas where conditions are more favourable when disturbance happens.

Where, then, shall we go to find plants that tolerate high levels of stress? Soils with extreme chemistry are one good example. Calcareous soils, those rich in calcium carbonate, have low levels of phosphate, an important nutrient. The species that occur on these soils are often highly specialised and are not found on soils with lower pH. The continuous stress in these habitats favours stress-tolerant species, the third of Grime’s three archetypal strategies. These plants are slow-growing and relatively small.

Stress-tolerant forbs growing in limestone pavement in the Burren.

In the Burren, a large area of limestone in Clare, specialised communities of stress-tolerant forbs are found. Thin layers of soil form on the limestone pavement, and these are covered by an extremely rich community of plants. Most of the species in the picture above are long-lived, small perennials. The grasses and sedges present are also relatively slow-growing, and are less dominant in the community than in one where light competition is more important.

Grime recognised that these three strategies are the extremes of a continuous spectrum of variation between different plants. Most species exhibit elements of all of these strategies, depending on the relative importance of competition, stress, and disturbance. The three archetypal strategies (Competitive, Stress-tolerant, and Ruderal) led to this theory being known as Grime's CSR.

Let's return to the question of why Yellow Rattle reduces the growth of grasses more than it does forbs. Tradeoffs can provide clues: different plants have different traits that correspond to their strategy in the CSR spectrum. Most grasses grow rapidly and invest few resources in defense relative to forbs. Their clonal growth also means when Yellow Rattle does attach to their roots, it is connecting to a large network of connected roots and rhizomes and can drain resources from across this network, while on forbs it can only access a relatively small root network.16 Not only that, but forbs are also generally better adapted to tolerating stress than grasses - an important difference in their CSR strategy. This may mean that Yellow Rattle is more effective at stealing the resources of grasses, leading to a larger decrease in their growth when it is present.

Thus, Yellow Rattle acts as an equalising mechanism17 under conditions where competitive grasses would normally dominate. It reduces differences in fitness between grasses and forbs, leading to coëxistence between the two groups. Note this effect is independent of the density of the plants involved, unlike Conspecific Negative Density Dependence.

Plant-soil feedbacks

Our understanding of Conspecific Negative Density Dependence would lead us to expect that a given plant will be under increased pressure from disease when it grows nearer to individuals of its own species. This can be extended to soil that plants of the same species have grown in in the past. The research tradition of plant-soil feedbacks considers the effect of pathogens in the soil.

Plant-soil feedbacks are measurable effects of soils on the growth of plants, depending on what plant species were growing in that soil previously. They are another lens through which to see the Janzen-Connell effect, and provide further strong evidence for the importance of this effect in plant communities. Much like crop rotation, plants grow more strongly in soils where the same species has not grown previously. This effect is strong enough in European grasslands to increase plant diversity.18

← Previous chapter

Next chapter →

References

  1. Bagchi, R., Swinfield, T., Gallery, R. E., Lewis, O. T., Gripenberg, S., Narayan, L., & Freckleton, R. P. (2010). Testing the Janzen-Connell mechanism: Pathogens cause overcompensating density dependence in a tropical tree. Ecology Letters, 13(10), 1262–1269. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1461-0248.2010.01520.x
  2. Janzen, D. H. (1970). Herbivores and the Number of Tree Species in Tropical Forests. The American Naturalist, 104(940), 501–528. https://doi.org/10.1086/282687
  3. Connell, J. H. (1971). On the role of natural enemies in preventing competitive exclusion in some marine animals and in rain forests. Dynamics of Populations (Oosterbeek 1970), 298–312. PDF available here.
  4. Gillett, J. B. (1962). Pest Pressure, an Underestimated Factor in Evolution. Systematics Association Publication Number 4: Taxonomy and Geography, 37–46. PDF available here.
  5. Gaston, K. J. (2000). Global patterns in biodiversity. Nature, 405, 220–227. https://doi.org/10.1038/35012228
  6. Liu, X., Parker, I. M., Gilbert, G. S., Lu, Y., Xiao, Y., Zhang, L., Huang, M., Cheng, Y., Zhang, Z., & Zhou, S. (2022). Coexistence is stabilized by conspecific negative density dependence via fungal pathogens more than oomycete pathogens. Ecology, 103(12). https://doi.org/10.1002/ecy.3841
  7. Ke, P.-J., & Wan, J. (2023). A general approach for quantifying microbial effects on plant competition. Plant and Soil, 485(1–2), 57–70. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11104-022-05744-3
  8. Davies, D. M., Graves, J. D., Elias, C. O., & Williams, P. J. (1997). The impact of Rhinanthus spp. On sward productivity and composition: Implications for the restoration of species-rich grasslands. Biological Conservation, 82(1), 87–93. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0006-3207(97)00010-4
  9. Pywell, R. F., Bullock, J. M., Walker, K. J., Coulson, S. J., Gregory, S. J., & Stevenson, M. J. (2004). Facilitating grassland diversification using the hemiparasitic plant Rhinanthus minor. Journal of Applied Ecology, 41(5), 880–887. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.0021-8901.2004.00940.x
  10. Mudrák, O., de Bello, F., Doležal, J., & Lepš, J. (2016). Changes in the functional trait composition and diversity of meadow communities induced by Rhinanthus minor L. Folia Geobotanica, 51(1), 1–11. https://doi.org/10.1007/S12224-016-9238-Z
  11. Chaudron, C., Mazalová, M., Kuras, T., Malenovský, I., & Mládek, J. (2021). Introducing ecosystem engineers for grassland biodiversity conservation: A review of the effects of hemiparasitic Rhinanthus species on plant and animal communities at multiple trophic levels. Perspectives in Plant Ecology, Evolution and Systematics, 52. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ppees.2021.125633
  12. Cameron, D. D., White, A., & Antonovics, J. (2009). Parasite–grass–forb interactions and rock–paper–scissor dynamics: Predicting the effects of the parasitic plant Rhinanthus minor on host plant communities. Journal of Ecology, 97(6), 1311–1319. https://doi.org/10.1111/J.1365-2745.2009.01568.X
  13. Dalzell, J. (2023). Modelling Yellow Rattle in a simulated grassland. Blogpost in Irish Plants. https://doi.org/10.59350/67z4n-k8h58
  14. Cameron, D. D., Coats, A. M., & Seel, W. E. (2006). Differential Resistance among Host and Non-host Species Underlies the Variable Success of the Hemi-parasitic Plant Rhinanthus minor. Annals of Botany, 98(6), 1289–1299. https://doi.org/10.1093/aob/mcl218
  15. Grime, J. P. (1974). Vegetation classification by reference to strategies. Nature, 250, 26–31. https://doi.org/10.1038/250026a0
  16. Demey, A., De Frenne, P., Baeten, L., Verstraeten, G., Hermy, M., Boeckx, P., & Verheyen, K. (2015). The effects of hemiparasitic plant removal on community structure and seedling establishment in semi-natural grasslands. Journal of Vegetation Science, 26(3), 409–420. https://doi.org/10.1111/JVS.12262
  17. Letten, A. D., Ke, P.-J., & Fukami, T. (2017). Linking modern coexistence theory and contemporary niche theory. Ecological Monographs, 87(2), 161–177. https://doi.org/10.1002/ecm.1242
  18. Petermann, J. S., Fergus, A. J. F., Turnbull, L. A., & Schmid, B. (2008). Janzen-Connell Effects Are Widespread and Strong Enough to Maintain Diversity in Grasslands. Ecology, 89(9), 2399–2406. https://doi.org/10.1890/07-2056.1